As a birthday treat to ourselves, my friend and I were accompanied by a couple dates to Top Chef’s Stephanie Izard’s thriving establishment in Near West Side, Chicago Girl & the Goat. My friend has the philosophy that you should always wait at least half a year before visiting a new establishment, “so they can get their shit together,” she says. I wholeheartedly agree and was very glad that I waited a while to visit Girl & the Goat, if only because it built up a lot of anticipation that was definitely satisfied.
There’s been a lot of hype about G&G, and even more competition created among gastropub, fine-dining establishments. It’s amazing how much my seemingly-insignificant hostess job opened me to the realm of the restaurant industry. The brute of what I learned: everyone knows everyone and they’re always in a polite, hospitable competition with each other. I’ve been exposed to a lot of mixed reviews about G&G (from personal references, rather than Yelp reviews), but I let go of all predispositions at the door.

Girl & the Goat entrance
The remainder of this post will be more like a photo-journal, for the beauty of the food speaks for itself. The four of us each chose a couple dishes from the menu (divided into vegetables, fish, meat and dessert sections) that we wished to contribute to our overall extravaganza, and we shared the plates family-style.
Let’s start with what every meal should always start with – a little pallet cleanser that flirts with your taste buds and arouses the senses. What else could this ideal appeteaser be, but…

raw oysters
You guessed it. Scrumptious raw oystaaaarrrrs. (I get passionate about these little guys.) G&G puts a tangy twist to their raw oysters that makes you wish the dish came with more than one succulent shell (resting upon a bed of dry black beans) per guest: raw shibumi, radish mignonette, and tarragon. Easy to slurp down, not so easy to pass the withdrawal syndrome (especially at $4 a pop).
Now for one of my choices, a little bit of light veggies to start our stomachs digesting nicely…

shaved squash and kohlrabi salad
The shaved squash and kohlrabi (German turnip) were complimented by fennel, evalon, toasted sliced almonds and ginger dressing. I’d been on a shaved squash kick since my short ribs at Lula’s and this definitely fulfilled my squash thirst. I loved the crisp of the shaved squash, crunchy and sweet – refreshing and quenching to my taste buds. It’s hard to get enough of this stuff.
Onward with the vegetables!

roasted beets
Beets rank as another one of my latest vegetable obsessions. This dish revealed a contrast of combined flavors with each bite. One bite would be sweet, juicy roasted beets; another, crispy salty green beans. My tongue was shocked by tangy white anchovy, then soothed by avocado creme fraiche. I tip my hat to the chef on this one.
The vegetable finale:

chickpeas fritters
This creation had a distinct Mediterranean influence consisting of chickpeas fritters, romesco, hazelnut hummus, sesame and goat feta. The flavors were interesting and there was definitely a kick to the fritters. However, I did not enjoy this dish as much as the rest of my party. It had a very nutty flavor (I don’t regularly like nuts), and there was an overbearing amount of creamy texture between the romesco, hummus and feta. My fellow guests devoured the plate…
This next dish was an unconventional, yet very appropriate transition from vegetable starters to meat plates.

ham frittes
I like french fries. I also dig bacon. But combine them into one creation, to me, sounds like a heart attack waiting to happen – a delicious heart attack. These fries aren’t made from ‘taters. This is deep fried, french-shaped pork fat for your gluttony enjoyment. On the side, the frittes are equipped with two dipping sauces: smoked tomato aioli (my favorite) and smoked swiss. The only problem with this dish – you can feel your health depleting with each bite, which only bothers me when I am trying to hold out strong for several more courses.
Time for some creations from the ocean:

grilled baby octopus
Octopus is a touchy subject. Most people don’t mind the flavor, but it’s the rubbery texture that gets them. A convenient way to reduce the squeaky-chewing side effect is with the use of a fiery grill. Now, an octopus is an octopus – there’s no way around that. But this dish accentuates the rich flavor of the underwater monster. I realize I am a huge fan of the grill/smoke flavor, so my perception of the plate is a little biased. I loved the variety of textures and bold flavor. The grilled baby octopus concoction included serrano, treviso, celery root, braised pistachio and “red bliss potato”.
Also under the sea…

escargot ravioli
This was another interesting dish. Escargot ravioli in a tamarind miso paste with brown butter, bok choy and topped with fried onions. I am used to my escargot cooked in a steaming mass of garlic, butter, herbs and breadcrumbs in one of those dishes that has tiny, escargot-sized holes. This was definitely a change in timbre from what I am always expecting escargot to taste like. To be honest, it threw me off a little, but after the initial shock, I was able to enjoy the rest of the portion.
Time to bring on the hearty goodness.

roasted lamb shank
I apologize for my lack of description on this next one. I know the dish included a roasted lamb shank, which was juicy and practically falling off the bone. Slightly bland in flavor, although that could be the “lamb flavor” which I’ll admit I am not that accustomed to. The lamb was complimented by sautéed apples and onions, herbs, and what I think was chorizo (judging by the textured dark matter on and around the shank). This dish was good, but I don’t recall it being one of my favorites.
This, however, was one of my favorites (if not the favorite):

seafood fideos
This delectable creation includes monk fish, mussels, button clams and rock shrimp, swimming in coconut milk and lemon grass. The taste reminded me of tom kha kai (my second favorite Thai soup). Served with a couple pieces of Serrano toast (you can see the green tint to the bread), this plate was the highlight of my night.
And the grandfather of foods I was reluctant to try this evening:

wood oven roasted pig face
The menu description reads as such, “wood oven roasted pig face . sunny side egg . tamarind . cilantro . potato stix.” I have to be honest, I almost did not try this one at all. I don’t often think of myself as a picky eater, but there are certain things I am hesitant to try (organs – save from liver, external appendages – like cock’s comb, pig feet, etc.). My date shares this notion with me, though he seemed to have gotten over many of his dietary restrictions of this meal already (lamb, octopus, etc.). But because this was an experience, we had to try everything. And to be honest (again), this was probably my second-favorite dish of the meal. The face meat was tender and flavorful, not the slimy mess I was expecting. The egg served as a perfect touch, showing the versatile nature of pork.
After this hearty meal, I felt surprisingly, pleasantly full – not overstuffed (like I probably should have been after 10 courses). Now comes for the after-meal treat. Like a smoker who fiends for a smoke after filling their tummy, I crave something, anything SWEET. Cue the dessert!

blood orange sorbet
After apologizing for this blurry shot, I shall provide you with the creation description from the menu: “blood orange sorbet . parsnip pot de creme . pistachio cake . three sisters cornmeal crust.” This was a great call by one of my fellow guests: a perfect, tangy, sweet sensation to follow the large variety of its precedents.
But wait, there’s more!

green hill cheese
I always love the idea of a cheese treat/tray before or after a meal. For me, it makes a perfect appetizer or dessert. The cheese menu offered four viable options, but I went for the classic cow’s milk choice: Green hill, sweet grass diary, Thomasville, GA. Crispy pita crackers and a berry chutney were perfect compliments.
The pairings in this picture consisted of the French pinot noir I had been sipping all evening and Christian Drouin calvados VSOP (and a small glass of water).
And also, a surprise…

bittersweet chocolate
I didn’t originally order this dessert because I wanted the cheese more for some reason. Maybe it was the shiitake gelato that threw me off, but I’m glad this one came! If you ask my mother, she will tell you that my first full sentence was “I need chocolate,” and I have sworn by that declarative ever since. This dessert truly melts in your mouth from the gelato, to the toffee creme fraiche. And 2 candles for the birthdays of 2 lovely ladies!
Menu items I wish I’d tired:
- kabocha squash ravioli . mushroom raisin ragout . brussels leaves . shroom creme fraiche
- seared scallops . brown butter XO . goat sausage . white shrimp . shiitakes . winter squash
- grilled skirt steak . chiogga beets . house pickles . wilted romaine . salted goat milk caramel
Other good things about G&G:
- Individual bathrooms: 4 woman’s, 2 men’s (smart planning)
- A rustic, contemporary setting, with seating that faces the kitchen line:

rustic atmosphere
- Funky artwork (painting by Chicago artist Quang Hong):

"girl and the goat"
- A spacious, well-stocked bar:

G&G bar
Downsides:
(only one) – We ordered the grilled seppia (with parsnip, sea beans, smoked tomato and avocado vinaigrette) per suggestion from our server and did not receive it. We realized when it was too late to check the bill, so that part was our own fault…
All in all, a wonderful experience. I was seriously impressed with G&G and cannot wait to return (probably on the next group special occasion). I’d say most (if not all) of the hype is well-deserved – it shows in the difficulty to get a weekend reservation. If you’re thinking about taking a visit to Girl & the Goat, I’d say that’s a very wise decision…
View Larger Map